Skip to main content

← Back to All Posts

Eleven real quoted heat pump offers, compared side by side.

R290 refrigerant, SCOP ratings, sound levels, net and gross prices, estimated BEG subsidy, local Modbus control — and which quotes hide surprises. Based on actual offers for a single-family house (~200 m², oil-to-heat-pump conversion). Personal data and vendor names generalized; this is a methodology example, not a live quote comparison.

Key Takeaways

  • Every modern heat pump in this comparison uses R290 (propane) refrigerant with GWP ~3 — future-proof and eligible for the BEG efficiency bonus.
  • Local control varies wildly: Stiebel Eltron and Tecalor offer official Modbus TCP via their ISG gateway; Panasonic relies on community HeishaMon; Viessmann is cloud-only (ViCare); Buderus has no end-customer Modbus.
  • After an estimated 35 % BEG subsidy (not guaranteed), net costs range from roughly €12,000 to €39,000 depending on brand, capacity and scope.
  • Oversizing is common: a 16 kW unit and a 22 kW unit were quoted for a renovated 200 m² house where ~10 kW fits. Oversized heat pumps cycle more, lose efficiency and cost more upfront.
  • Always demand a DIN 12831 heat load calculation before signing — it's the only defensible basis for sizing and often required for subsidy applications.
EnergyOS energy systems overview demo data: PV, grid import/export, battery, house consumption and self-consumption share with per-system tiles

Demo data in EnergyOS: live energy flow with per-system tiles for heat pump, PV, battery and grid meter.

What to Compare in a Heat Pump Offer

Before looking at prices, check these seven specifications. A cheaper quote with the wrong capacity or no local control can cost more over the system's life. For a broader context on energy management systems, see our guide to what an EMS is and what it does not do.

The 11 Offers at a Glance

The table below generalizes vendor names (personal data removed) but keeps the real technical data and price structure from the quoted offers. Prices are net (before 19 % VAT) unless noted. The "after BEG" column estimates 35 % subsidy on eligible costs — this is not guaranteed and depends on KfW/BAFA approval at application time.

SpecificationWhat good looks likeWhy it matters
Heating capacity (kW)Matched to your DIN 12831 heat load, not your old boiler's sizeOversized units cycle on and off, losing efficiency and comfort.
SCOP / JAZSCOP ≥ 4.5 @ 35 °C flow temperature (A+++ class)Higher SCOP means less electricity per kWh of heat, every year.
Refrigerant & GWPR290 (propane), GWP ~3Future-proof against F-gas phase-down; qualifies for BEG efficiency bonus.
Sound power Lw (dB(A))≤ 50 dB(A) rated, with night/reduced modeQuiet units matter if the outdoor unit sits near bedrooms or property lines.
Local control / ModbusOfficial local API (Modbus TCP), not cloud-onlyLets you integrate with Home Assistant, EnergyOS or your own automation.
PV-surplus heatingSG-Ready or Modbus setpoint control from your HEMSEnables running the heat pump on your own PV electricity instead of grid power.
Scope inclusionsOld-heating removal, hydraulic balancing, electrical work, grid registration listed explicitlyMissing line items become expensive change orders later.
#Brand & model (generalized)CapacitySCOP @35 °CPrice netPrice grossEst. after BEG (35 %)RefrigerantSound LwLocal control
1Stiebel Eltron WPL-A 13.2 + DHW + buffer13.92 kW max @ A7/W354.65~€33,100~€39,400~€22,900R29049 dB(A)✅ Official Modbus TCP via ISG
2Tecalor TTL 10.1 ACS eco10 kW4.65~€30,200~€35,900~€21,200R29049 dB(A)✅ Official Modbus TCP via ISG
3Panasonic Aquarea T-CAP M-Series16 kWNot stated~€32,300~€38,400~€22,600R29029 dB(A) whisper❌ Community HeishaMon only
4Viessmann Vitocal 250-A16 kWNot stated~€32,800~€39,000~€22,800R290Quiet, dB not stated❌ ViCare cloud-only
5Viessmann Vitocal (rental)kW TBDNot statedLease / moLease / mon/aR290Not stated❌ Cloud-only, leased hardware
6Buderus Logatherm WLW176/186i AR10–12 kWCOP ~4.84 @ A7/W35~€45,000 turnkey~€45,000~€31,500R290Not stated❌ No end-customer Modbus
7Buderus Logatherm WLW186i ARNot statedNot stated~€37,800~€45,000~€26,500R290Not stated❌ No end-customer Modbus
8PHNIX GreenTherm22 kWNot stated~€29,300~€34,900~€20,500R290Not stated❌ Modbus poorly documented
9Stiebel Eltron WPL-A 10.2~10 kW class~4.65~€22,300~€26,600~€12,000R290~49 dB(A)✅ Official Modbus TCP via ISG
10Stiebel Eltron WPL-A 10.2 Plus~10 kW class~4.x~€22,300~€26,600~€12,000R290Not stated✅ Official Modbus TCP via ISG
11Buderus WLW-10 MB AR10 kWSCOP good, JAZ varies~€29,900~€35,600~€20,900R290Not stated❌ SG-Ready only
12Zewo ALPHA G15 kW nominal5.58 @ 35 °C~€35,400~€35,400~€24,800R290Not stated❌ No documented local Modbus

Prices from offer PDFs dated 2026-02 to 2026-07. "Est. after BEG" assumes 35 % subsidy on eligible costs (realistic for household income above €40,000); BEG caps eligible costs at €28,000 for the first unit. Some offers may be expired or have lapsed validity — always re-quote before signing.

What the Price Includes — and What's Missing

Line itemTypically includedOften missing — ask
Old heating removalMost offers include boiler + tank disposalOil tank decommissioning is often extra (up to €7,000 for large tanks)
Hydraulic balancingIncluded in top offers (e.g. Verfahren B)Some quotes don't list it — required for efficient operation
Electrical workVaries; some include full installationSPD/surge protection, new circuits, distribution board upgrades
Grid registrationLarge operators often include MaStR + EVUSmaller installers may leave it to you ("not explicit — confirm")
Heat load calculationIncluded in engineering-heavy offersSome quotes have no kW figure — demand one before signing

Missing line items become expensive change orders later. Before signing, ask for a written scope that lists: demolition and disposal of the old boiler, oil/tank decommissioning if applicable, electrical connection (including any needed circuits and distribution board upgrades), grid registration (MaStR, EVU registration, An-/Fertigmeldung), heat-load calculation, and hydraulic balancing.

Never size a heat pump from your old boiler's nameplate or from square footage alone. A DIN 12831 heat load calculation (method B, room-by-room) is the defensible basis — and is often required for BEG subsidy applications. Rule-of-thumb sizing is how you end up with an oversized, inefficient system.

Local Control: The Difference That Matters Most

Local control determines whether you can integrate your heat pump with Home Assistant, EnergyOS, or your own automation — or whether you're locked into a vendor's cloud app. This is the single biggest differentiator between the offers. Note that UtilityControl handles meter readings and utility bills separately from EnergyOS — don't confuse the two.

Control typeOffersWhat it means in practice
✅ Official local Modbus TCPStiebel Eltron WPL-A (via ISG web/ISG plus, port 502), Tecalor TTL (via ISG)Documented register map, read+write from Home Assistant, works without internet, vendor-supported.
⚠️ Community reverse-engineeredPanasonic Aquarea (via HeishaMon on ESP32 at CN-CNT port)Mature community solution but unofficial; no vendor support; breaks on firmware changes.
❌ Cloud-only APIViessmann Vitocal (ViCare), Viessmann rentalVendor cloud required; local Optolink exists but is service-tool only, not for automation.
❌ No end-customer ModbusBuderus Logatherm WLW176/186iUsers with identical hardware report no accessible Modbus; EEBus to SMA Sunny Home Manager possible but not DIY-friendly.
❌ SG-Ready only / unclearBuderus WLW-10 MB AR, Zewo ALPHA G, PHNIX GreenThermBasic on/off via SG-Ready relay; fine-grained control (setpoints, modulation) not documented.

Oversizing Warning: Bigger Is Not Better

Two offers stand out as likely oversized for a renovated ~200 m² single-family house:

  • Offer 3 (Panasonic 16 kW) — likely oversized. The house's modeled post-renovation heat demand points to ~10 kW. A 16 kW unit will cycle frequently in mild weather, losing efficiency and comfort.
  • Offer 8 (PHNIX 22 kW) — very large / likely heavily oversized. At 22 kW for this house, short-cycling is almost certain.

By contrast, Offers 9 and 10 (Stiebel Eltron WPL-A 10.2) sit at ~10 kW — a good match for the ~10 kW target. Offer 11 (Buderus WLW-10 MB) also fits at 10 kW nominal. A 16 kW unit and especially a 22 kW unit add significant cost without meaningful benefit for this house.

Never size a heat pump from your old boiler's nameplate or from square footage alone. A DIN 12831 heat load calculation (method B, room-by-room) is the defensible basis — and is often required for BEG subsidy applications. Rule-of-thumb sizing is how you end up with an oversized, inefficient system.

Bottom line: if you want to run your heat pump from Home Assistant or integrate it into an energy platform, Stiebel Eltron and Tecalor with ISG are the only offers with official, documented local Modbus TCP. Everything else is either community-hacked, cloud-dependent, or unverified.

How We Chose the 11 Offers

The comparison includes all concrete, priced heat-pump offers available for the project at the time of writing, plus a few notable near-misses (rental template, oversized units). The selection was driven by one question: if you are standing at the same point — a renovated house, ~10 kW of heat-pump capacity needed, Home Assistant integration desired — which quotes give you the best combination of price, efficiency, local control and vendor support?

EnergyOS and Heat Pump Integration

EnergyOS does not sell or install heat pumps — it manages them after installation. EnergyOS speaks MQTT over TLS and works through gateways (Home Assistant, Node-RED, evcc) that exchange flat JSON with the platform.

If your heat pump has official local Modbus TCP (Stiebel Eltron and Tecalor with ISG), a Home Assistant or Node-RED gateway can read values and write setpoints, and EnergyOS can orchestrate PV-surplus heating rules via SG-Ready or Modbus setpoints. Cloud-only units (Viessmann ViCare) limit what local automation can do — you're dependent on the vendor's API and internet connection.

EnergyOS does not talk to every device by itself. Equipment still connects through a gateway. EnergyOS and UtilityControl are separate products with separate accounts: UtilityControl handles meter readings and utility bills; EnergyOS handles energy systems, consulting and remote device management.

alt="EnergyOS heat pump history chart and SG Ready controls showing operating modes and temperature curves" width="1280" height="1320" loading="lazy">

EnergyOS heat pump view: history chart, SG Ready control modes, and per-system status tiles.

Compare energy management on your own data

EnergyOS has a free plan and a demo mode with simulated systems, so you can see the overview, history charts and rules before connecting any equipment. For projects, integrations or partnerships, request a meeting.

Try EnergyOS Free Request a Meeting

No credit card required

Frequently Asked Questions

What is R290 and why does it matter?

R290 is propane used as a heat-pump refrigerant. It has a GWP (global warming potential) of ~3 — essentially negligible compared to older refrigerants like R410A (GWP ~2,088). It's future-proof against the EU F-gas phase-down and qualifies heat pumps for the BEG efficiency bonus.

Is a higher-capacity heat pump always better?

No. An oversized heat pump cycles on and off frequently, loses efficiency, delivers poorer comfort, and costs more upfront. Size should come from a DIN 12831 heat load calculation matched to your building's actual heat demand — not from your old boiler's nameplate.

Can I control my heat pump from Home Assistant?

It depends on the brand. Stiebel Eltron and Tecalor offer official local Modbus TCP via their ISG gateway — Home Assistant integration is documented and vendor-supported. Panasonic works through community HeishaMon (unofficial). Viessmann is cloud-only (ViCare). Buderus has no end-customer Modbus. Always confirm before buying if local control matters to you.

How much is the BEG subsidy for a heat pump?

The base grant is 30 % of eligible costs for replacing oil/gas heating. A speed bonus (+20 %) applies when replacing a working fossil heater. An income bonus (+30 %) applies up to €30,000 household income. The maximum combined rate is 70 %, on eligible costs capped at €28,000 for the first unit. Above €40,000 income, roughly 35 % is realistic — but only after KfW/BAFA approval. Apply before ordering.

Does EnergyOS sell or install heat pumps?

No. EnergyOS is an energy-management platform that coordinates heat pumps, PV, batteries and EV chargers after they're installed. It connects through gateways (Home Assistant, Node-RED, evcc) using MQTT over TLS. It does not replace your heating installer or a certified heat-load calculation.

Sources

  • Real quoted heat-pump offers (generalized), single project, offer PDFs dated 2026-02 to 2026-07 — methodology example, not a live quote comparison. Personal data and vendor names removed.
  • KfW 458 — Energieeffizient Bauen und Sanieren, residential heat-pump grant (accessed 2026-11-19).
  • Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Klimaschutz (BMWK): BEG guideline, 17 July 2026.
  • Stiebel Eltron: Modbus TCP/IP documentation for ISG web / ISG plus.
  • Bundesverband Wärmepumpe (BWP): SG Ready label description.
  • EnergyOS product documentation by QLines, state of 19 November 2026.

Last updated: 19 November 2026.

What is UtilityControl?

UtilityControl is a comprehensive web-based application designed for monitoring, tracking, and managing utility consumption across multiple locations. It supports electricity, water, gas, and heating meters with analytics and cost tracking.

Learn more about UtilityControl →

How to Get Started

  1. Sign up for free at qlines.net - no credit card required
  2. Add your meters - configure electricity, water, gas, or heating meters with custom names and units
  3. Start logging readings - enter meter readings manually or import from CSV files
  4. Analyze your consumption - view interactive charts, track costs, and identify usage patterns
  5. Use mobile app - download the iOS app for on-the-go meter tracking

Explore More Solutions

QLines offers comprehensive platform solutions beyond utility tracking. Explore all our solutions for device monitoring, remote programming, and centralized management.